The best Christmas desserts bring a little variety to the holiday table: something chocolate, something spiced, and a favorite pie or cake worth saving room for. These 16 JenniferCooks recipes include Southern pies, festive layer cakes, creamy cheesecakes, puddings, and Christmas cookies. Start with one centerpiece dessert, then add a contrasting flavor or a small cookie platter if your gathering calls for more. You will find the recipes grouped below so you can choose by dessert type, followed by a practical guide to cooling, chilling, oven space, and serving. Open each recipe for its complete ingredients, method, and storage directions.
Jump to: Pies · Cakes and cheesecakes · Puddings and trifles · Cookies
Christmas Pies for the Holiday Table
Choose a pie for the flavors your guests love: pecans and brown sugar, tangy vanilla custard, spiced apples, or chocolate mousse. Check cooling and chilling times before choosing your baking day.
Old-Fashioned Buttermilk Pie Recipe
A sweet vanilla custard pie with a gentle buttermilk tang and golden top.
Classic Apple Pie
Granny Smith apples and cinnamon-brown sugar filling inside a golden double crust.
Christmas Cakes and Cheesecakes
A layer cake makes a striking centerpiece, while cheesecake offers a creamy contrast to holiday baking. Mini cheesecakes give guests an individual portion with chocolate, caramel, and pecans.
Red Velvet Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting
Tender red velvet cake layers paired with cream cheese frosting.
Homemade German Chocolate Cake
Three chocolate cake layers covered with cooked coconut-pecan frosting.
Mini Turtle Cheesecakes
Individual cheesecakes topped with chocolate chips, pecans, and melted caramel.
Christmas Puddings and Trifles
These spoonable desserts bring a different texture to the table. Choose warm date cake with toffee sauce, a chocolate trifle with Baileys, or a no-bake banana pudding layered with Biscoff cookies. The Baileys trifle contains alcohol; keep that in mind when planning for your guests.
Baileys Chocolate Cheesecake Trifle
Layers of espresso-soaked Oreos, chocolate cheesecake filling, and Baileys whipped cream.
Biscoff Banana Pudding
No-bake banana pudding with Biscoff cookies, cookie butter, and Heath toffee bits.
Christmas Cookies for a Dessert Platter
Finish the spread with a few small bites. Chocolate crinkles, ginger molasses cookies, decorated sugar cutouts, and fruit cake macaroons bring chocolate, spice, and festive color without another full-size dessert.
Soft and Chewy Ginger Molasses Cookies
Soft, chewy molasses cookies with ginger, cinnamon, and cloves.
Soft Cut-Out Sugar Cookies
Buttery vanilla-almond sugar cookie cutouts ready for your favorite icing.
How to Choose a Balanced Christmas Dessert Menu
For a small gathering, one pie or cake can be enough. For a larger table, choose contrasting flavors and textures: a rich chocolate dessert alongside a fruit pie, or a creamy cheesecake alongside spiced cookies. Two desserts that taste different give guests a more useful choice than several versions of the same flavor.
A Southern dessert table could pair pecan pie with buttermilk pie and ginger molasses cookies. A chocolate-focused spread could start with German chocolate cake and add mini turtle cheesecakes. For a menu with less last-minute baking, choose classic cheesecake or Biscoff banana pudding and prepare the cookies separately.
Use the yields in the individual recipes when planning quantities. Ask about guest preferences before shopping, and check each ingredient list for nuts, dairy, eggs, wheat, and other ingredients your guests need to avoid. The Baileys trifle also needs a separate decision about alcohol.
What to Make Ahead for Christmas
Give chilled desserts their own calendar slot. Classic cheesecake needs an overnight chill. Biscoff banana pudding needs at least three hours, with overnight preferred. The Baileys trifle needs at least four hours in the refrigerator. Reserve refrigerator space as well as preparation time.
Bake pies with cooling time in mind. Pecan pie supports baking a day ahead and refrigerating. Buttermilk pie needs cooling and chilling before serving. Apple pie needs a full three hours of cooling before slicing. French silk pie chills for several hours or overnight.
Spread out cake preparation. The red velvet cake layers can be baked a day ahead. German chocolate cake and carrot cake both support making unfrosted layers ahead; follow their wrapping and storage directions, then allow time for frosting and assembly.
Count dough chilling as preparation. Chocolate crinkle dough needs at least four hours in the refrigerator. The sugar cutout dough needs at least two hours and can be refrigerated for up to three days. Icing and decorating belong on the timeline too.
Serving Desserts Without Crowding the Kitchen
Before Christmas Day, compare the oven temperatures, pan sizes, cooling periods, and refrigerator space your chosen desserts require. Finish desserts with long chilling times before the main meal takes over the kitchen. A no-bake dessert frees oven space but still needs a place to chill.
Set out the serving plate, cake knife, pie server, and small dessert plates before dinner. Keep chilled desserts refrigerated until you are ready to serve, following the individual recipes. Put cookies on their own platter so guests can choose a small bite alongside a slice.
Sticky toffee pudding has a final sauce-and-broiler step just before serving. Choose it when you can leave room for that finishing work after dinner. For a more relaxed dessert service, a chilled pie or cheesecake avoids that last-minute oven step.
More Help for Your Holiday Baking
For homemade pastry, see my buttery flaky pie crust and guide to blind-baking pie crusts. For decorated sugar cookies, use my royal icing for cookies recipe.
What Is Always on Your Christmas Dessert Table?
Which dessert would your family miss if it were not on the Christmas table? Leave a comment below, and join my email list for more recipes from my kitchen.
This post may contain affiliate links. I may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.























Comments
No Comments