The Classic Godfather Cocktail (Scotch & Amaretto)

Get ready to shake things up with the Godfather cocktail, a deliciously simple mix of Scotch and amaretto that blends the nutty sweetness of amaretto with a spicy whiskey kick. Why not mix one up tonight and enjoy a drink that's as flavorful as it is easy to make? Cheers!

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

Every February, my husband and I toast to another trip around the sun together, and this year we decided to do it up right at a swanky local steakhouse. Our night out took a terrific twist when we stumbled upon the Godfather cocktail on the menu—a cozy little mix of Scotch and amaretto that seriously wowed us. It's amazing how a drink with just two ingredients can pack such a punch and wrap us up in its rich, spirited history!

This classic cocktail, much like the early 1970s film featuring the legendary Marlon Brando, packs a punch with just two main ingredients: Scotch whisky and almond-flavored liqueur. It's a perfect example of how less can be so much more.

The Godfather cocktail recipe calls for equal parts Scotch and amaretto, stirred over a large ice cube in a rocks glass, and it's just the thing to cozy up with on a cold night.

Now, let's dive into what makes this drink a fan favorite. When it comes to the base spirit, Scotch whisky, you can go with a hearty blended Scotch or a fancy single malt—both are fantastic choices, so just pick whatever suits your taste! The almond liqueur, typically amaretto, adds a touch of sweetness that complements the smoky notes of the whisky beautifully. And when these ingredients mingle in an ice-filled glass, they create a sipping sensation that's hard to beat.

For those who love a good story, the Godfather cocktail has a spirited one. It's said to have been a favorite of Marlon Brando himself, which adds a dash of Hollywood glam to every glass. The drink's origins are a bit murky, just like the dealings of the Corleone family, with some attributing its creation to the popularity of the film and others to the ingenuity of bartenders from that era.

Godfather Cocktail Variations

Feeling adventurous? The Godfather cocktail lends itself to some fun variations. Swap out the Scotch for rye whiskey and you’ve got yourself a Brooklyn Godfather. Add a splash of ginger ale for a fizzy twist, or throw in a little bitters and an orange peel to spice things up. And for those extra chilly evenings, a Godfather warmed up with a shot of espresso can transform into an espresso martini Godfather style.

If you feel like jazzing it up, there are plenty of twists on the classic Godfather to explore. Want to swap out the amaretto for something with a bit more zing? Try the Rusty Nail, which throws Drambuie into the mix for an herbal kick. Or go for a French Connection with some smooth Cognac in place of the Scotch.

Swap out the Scotch for vodka and you've got yourself a Godmother cocktail. Looking for something a bit creamier? Just add cream to a Godfather to whip up a Godson. And if you do the same to a Godmother, voilà, you have a delightful Goddaughter. These riffs on the original are perfect for shaking things up and finding your favorite flavor.

Mixing this cocktail is a breeze, and here’s how you do it: Typically, the drink is made by mixing equal parts of Scotch whisky and amaretto. For this concoction, no hard rules dictate the choice of Scotch—whether it’s a single malt or a blended Scotch like Johnnie Walker, the key is enjoying the whisky’s interplay with the almond sweetness of the amaretto (we love Disaronnos Amaretto).

How to Make The Godfather

To make a Godfather cocktail, you'll need a mixing glass. Start by adding ice—preferably a large ice cube to slow down dilution. Then pour in your chosen Scotch and amaretto, usually in equal parts, though some prefer to adjust the ratios to taste. Stir the mix gently until well chilled and then strain it into a rocks glass over fresh ice, ideally an ice ball for an added touch of elegance.

As for serving, the classic way to enjoy a Godfather is neat, letting the natural flavors of the Scotch and amaretto shine through. But don’t be afraid to get creative with garnishes—an aromatic bitters or a maraschino liqueur drizzle can add an extra layer of flavor that makes the cocktail even more irresistible.

The Godfather is more than just a drink; it's a classic cocktail with a charm that keeps us coming back for more. It's the perfect mix for Scotch enthusiasts eager to try something new and for anyone who loves a drink with a deep, rich backstory.

So, the next time you find yourself pondering over what to sip on at your next party or while lounging by the fireplace, remember the Godfather cocktail. Whether you're hosting a swanky soiree or just winding down after a long day, this two-ingredient wonder will make you feel like a star in your own classic film. Here’s to delicious simplicity and cocktails that tell a story. Cheers to creating unforgettable moments with every clink of the glass!

Visit my Amazon Store for everything you need to cook up a storm, bake delicious treats, and whip up your favorite beverages!

Craving another classic cocktail? Try the French Martini!