Buy Now → This bourbon Godfather cocktail combines sweet amaretto, aromatic bitters, and fresh orange oils for a rich, nutty drink you can stir together in five minutes.
Substitutions: Replace the bourbon with Scotch for a more traditional version. For a less sweet drink, reduce the amaretto to 1 fluid ounce. If needed, substitute another aromatic bitters; the flavor will change slightly.
Serving suggestions and pairings: Serve with salted nuts, aged cheddar, or dark chocolate.
Storage: For advance preparation, combine the bourbon, amaretto, and bitters in a sealed container and refrigerate for up to 1 week. Add ice and stir just before serving; garnish with freshly cut orange peel.